REDEFINING BIM 4D EXECUTION USING AUTOMATION

The architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) industry continues to undergo digital transformation, with Building Information Modeling (BIM) at the forefront of this evolution. Among its multidimensional capabilities, 4D BIM - the integration of time-related data into 3D models has emerged as a critical asset in construction planning and management. By linking project schedules with design models, 4D BIM enables stakeholders to visualize construction sequences, anticipate conflicts, and make informed decisions well before work begins on site.

However, manually managing the link between models and schedules becomes time consuming and error prone. This is where automation in 4D BIM becomes not just valuable, but necessary. Automating key processes such as schedule integration, selection set creation, and model linking significantly reduces manual workload, enhances data accuracy, and accelerates project timelines. In the sections that follow, the reshaping of BIM 4D workflows through automation will be explored for Admin Building structure at Mandya WSS project, along with the benefits delivered to project outcomes.

Authored by
Shameem Ashraf E
Sr. Design Engineer (Civil)
WWW SBG - EDRC, WET IC

Challenges in BIM 4D Workflows

Despite the growing adoption of 4D BIM in construction planning, traditional workflows often rely heavily on manual inputs, fragmented tools, and repetitive tasks that hinder efficiency and accuracy. Several recurring challenges are observed across projects, especially when scaling up to complex or fast-paced environments.

Flow chart showing conventional BIM 4D workflow

Key Challenges:

  • Manual Simulation ID Creation and Linking to Model Elements Simulation ID, which is essential for linking model elements with schedule tasks, are typically created manually in Excel or scheduling tools and then assigned individually within the BIM model. This manual process is time-consuming and increases the risk of errors and coordination delays in complex projects.
  • Activity wise Simulation ID assignation to BIM model

  • Inconsistent Data Structures BIM models and schedule data often originate from different teams or software platforms, leading to inconsistencies in naming conventions, simulation IDs, or categorization. This lack of standardization complicates the linking process and undermines simulation accuracy.
  • Selection Set Creation In tools like Bexel Manager, selection sets are often created manually for filtering or assigning tasks. This repetitive task consumes significant time, especially when large models and numerous simulation IDs are involved.
  • Manual schedule integration into 4D modeling software 4D modeling tools, such as Bexel Manager, are designed to accept schedule inputs in standardized formats like Microsoft Project (MSP) or Primavera (P6) only. This requirement can pose a challenge when schedules are initially prepared in Excel, as it introduces an additional conversion step before integration with the 4D environment.
  • An illustration of manual schedule preparation

  • Lack of Update Flexibility When design revisions or schedule updates occur, traditional 4D workflows require significant rework. Relinking tasks, regenerating selection sets, and validating every change manually adds risk and effort.
  • Limited Scalability As project complexity increases, traditional methods fail to scale efficiently. Handling large number of activities and model elements using manual processes leads to delays, coordination issues, and misalignment between planned and actual progress.

Overcoming challenges through BIM 4D Automation Workflow

To address the limitations of traditional 4D workflows, a comprehensive automation pipeline was adopted, streamlining every critical stage from schedule creation to 4D BIM simulation. This workflow eliminates repetitive manual tasks, ensures consistency across platforms, and significantly reduces the time required to generate accurate BIM 4D simulations. This solution is deployed with a web app for scheduling and Custom Add-ins for Revit and Bexel Manger for the automation of internal operations.

Flow chart showing BIM 4D automation workflow

The process begins with a web application for automated schedule preparation. Unlike traditional methods where users manually type task details, this application requires no direct data input. Instead, users simply select task names from a predefined dropdown list. Once a task is selected, all associated activities are automatically populated in a structured, hierarchical order. This eliminates typing errors and ensures schedule consistency, making it possible to prepare even complex construction schedules rapidly and with minimal effort.

Web App for BIM 4D automation – Interface for creating new schedule

Once all the hierarchical tasks have been selected, the process moves to automated Simulation ID generation. A unique Simulation ID can be automatically generated for each activity using predefined logic. These IDs serve as the key link between the schedule and the model elements.

Generated Simulation IDs

Since 4D platforms like Bexel Manager require the schedule to be in a specific format (Microsoft Project or Primavera), the workflow includes automated conversion of the created schedule into MSP-compatible XML format. This conversion ensures that the schedule can be imported directly into the 4D modeling software without additional formatting or manual intervention. Once the schedule is submitted, An MSP compatible XML schedule file and an excel based schedule file will be generated and the user must attach the input Revit file for parameter assignation.

Generated MSP compatible XML schedule file

Generated Excel schedule file

Following this, Revit will run in the background and the system creates a new Simulation ID parameter. This parameter is added automatically to all relevant model elements and the simulation ID generated will be added to the respective model elements driven by a custom developed add-in and the Revit file will be exported as BX3 file. This establishes the foundation for accurate linking between model and schedule.

Addin Created in Revit for automated Simulation ID assignation

Generated parameters and Simulation IDs assigned to respective elements using Addin

Subsequently, Bexel Manager launches automatically, and a new project will be created using the exported BX3 file. The workflow then continues with the automatic creation of selection sets through a custom-developed Bexel add-in. These sets are generated based on the Simulation IDs already embedded in the model and are organized into structured folders automatically. Following this, the system imports the previously generated XML schedule into Bexel Manager and automatically links all schedule activities with their corresponding model elements using the predefined selection sets. And the 4D simulation will be created and finally the output BX3 file will be downloaded to the user.

Addin created in Bexel Manager to generate selection sets based on Simulation ID

This fully automated process ensures seamless and accurate 4D linking, eliminating the need for manual mapping and significantly accelerating simulation setup. This end-to-end automation workflow ensures minimal manual effort, maximum accuracy, and a repeatable, scalable workflow suitable for complex project environments.

Generated Selection sets based on Activity Simulation ID

In addition to baseline schedule generation, the web application also supports the creation and editing of actual schedules. By referencing the previously generated baseline schedule, users can efficiently update task progress and enter actual start and finish dates. This extended functionality enables seamless delay analysis using the 4D model. This capability empowers project teams to visually compare planned versus actual progress within the 4D environment, enabling data-driven decisions and proactive project control.

Created list of downloadable schedule files & option for updating the actual schedule

Key Benefits

  • Time Reduction Schedule preparation and 4D simulation setup time reduced from days to minutes
  • Error Elimination Automated processes remove manual typing errors and incorrect linking
  • Consistent Data Structure: Standardized naming conventions for simulation ID formats across all elements
  • Enhanced ScalabilityHandles large numbers of activities and model elements without proportional effort increases
  • Rapid Updates Quick regeneration of simulation IDs and links when design or schedule changes occur
  • Real-Time Progress Monitoring Enables seamless delay analysis of planned versus actual progress for proactive control
  • Eliminates Additional Scheduling Software Web-based schedule creation removes dependency on separate scheduling applications

Created 4D model simulations at different construction phases

Implementation Requirements & Encountered Challenges

Automating the BIM 4D workflow demands both technical setup and strategic coordination across platforms, aligning the BIM model and schedule into a unified pipeline.

  • File Format Compatibility Since Bexel Manager only accepts MSP/Primavera inputs, the workflow auto-converts Excel schedules to MSP-compatible XML, preserving structure and Simulation IDs.
  • Required file conversion for the adopted workflow

  • Standard BIM model The BIM model must follow ISO 19650 standards with proper categorization to ensure reliable Simulation ID assignment and downstream automation.
  • ISO 19650 compliance with BIM model

  • Revit Addin for auto - parameter generation and assignation A custom Revit add-in is required which automates the creation and assignment of Simulation ID parameters to model elements.
  • Bexel Addin for auto - selection set generation A custom Bexel Manager add-in automates the generation of structured selection sets from the embedded Simulation IDs, enabling accurate 4D linkage

Future Enhancements and Potential Extensions

While the current 4D automation workflow streamlines schedule creation, model linking, and simulation generation for predefined project types, future development aims to expand the system’s adaptability, scalability, and intelligence to support a broader range of construction scenarios.

  • Scalable AdaptabilityTo support any type of structure, the workflow must evolve with dynamic rules for task breakdown and Simulation ID assignment, ensuring performance and automation consistency across varying project scales.
  • Smarter Activity MappingFuture upgrades may integrate rule-based or AI-driven systems to auto-detect model elements and assign tasks, minimizing manual input and improving efficiency.
  • AI driven activity generation and mapping to BIM model

  • Enhanced API IntegrationAs API capabilities advance, the workflow will leverage direct platform integration to eliminate any manual steps and scale solution for broader adoption.

Summary

This automated BIM 4D workflow tackles key challenges in construction planning by replacing manual, error-prone processes with a streamlined, integrated solution. Starting from schedule preparation, the system automates Simulation ID generation, converts schedules into MSP-compatible formats, and integrates seamlessly with Revit and Bexel Manager.

With its integration into a web-based platform, the solution unifies data preparation, model enhancement, and simulation—boosting productivity and enabling repeatable, advanced 4D planning. Future upgrades will target support for larger, more complex projects, driving wider adoption of automation in BIM 4D workflows.

;